When you think about it, it is ridiculous.
In fact, it would be pitiful, if they were
not so serious and did not have the power to do seriously bad things.
I am referring to the leaders of the Group of
20 (G-20) nations, who recently met in Mexico, thinking that they run the
world.
If the question were put to you, “Who runs the world?” there
could be several correct answers, but none of them would be this group of
people, or any subset of them. Nevertheless,
because they think that they do run the world, and because they act on that
belief, they do a lot of things that not only do not work but that make things
worse. Then they gather again and try
something else, much of which is designed to clean up the mess caused by their
previous foray in hubristic action.
The world is a complex place, with billions of people each
doing complex things and interacting with each other in complex ways. Then the planet itself does a lot of complex
things. Take the weather, for
instance. With computers and a hundred
years of scientific study, weather forecasters have succeeded in the ability to
predict the weather with a passable
degree of accuracy two or three days out.
Beyond that, the accuracy of forecasts declines to about 50-50 (flip a
coin) and drops from there. The ability
to change the weather, after a lot of work and investment, remains elusive.
You have to be very smart, or think that you are, to
convince yourself that you can in any significant way control the economy of
your own nation, let alone of the world together. The Russians, who are very smart people,
tried it for 70 years with less than success and with the death and misery of
tens of millions of their people. The
communist Chinese gave it a go, too.
Lately they have been reluctantly recognizing that there might be a
better way—though they act like they are still not so sure.
Consider how many of the most serious problems facing
mankind today are caused by people like these G-20 government leaders who fancy
that they run things. A few examples:
- The economic malaise in the United States. The U.S. economy has just passed through
a very deep recession, caused by government programs that encouraged
people to buy houses that they could not afford, investors to invest in
the mortgages used to buy those houses, banks to take government
investments in their capital that they did not need, and people who could
afford to pay their mortgages to walk away and leave the keys on the
counter. To solve those problems,
the U.S. government spent a trillion dollars it did not have, increased
rules and regulations on businesses that could otherwise create new jobs, “created”
a quarter of a million new jobs at the cost of eliminating a million jobs
in the private sector, and threatened investors and small businessmen with
stiff tax increases. Economic activity remains in the doldrums.
- The second economic recession in Europe. The European economy went into recession
about the same time that the U.S. economy did, for rather similar
reasons. It then weakly recovered,
briefly, and then went back into recession when the promises that the
governments of southern European countries made over decades to buy votes
at last became more expensive than they could borrow money for—let alone
pay for. Now, every couple of weeks
Greece, Italy, or Spain goes into economic crisis, the rest of the
European leaders make empty promises to solve the problem, followed a
couple of weeks later by new crisis and another round of promises. That has been going on for about a year,
while economic activity heads south.
- The availability of energy.
From the gasoline that we put in our cars, the electricity that
lights our houses, to the natural gas that warms our offices and homes
government rules affect the availability, price, distribution, and supply
of energy. The United States
imports enormous amounts of oil from unstable countries that use the money
we pay for it to threaten our people at home and abroad. Meanwhile, we have more than enough
supplies of coal, natural gas, and oil located in oil shale and oil sands
and off our own shores to meet all of our needs now and for the
foreseeable future, but government efforts to run the energy business
prevent us from using them.
These are just three groups of examples of many.
Once again I call on the wisdom of William
Tecumseh Sherman, the great Union general of the Civil War, who famously
refused to run for President of the United States with the assertion that if
nominated he would not run, if elected he would not serve.
He gave his friend and colleague, U.S. Grant,
who did not make such a refusal, a piece of excellent advice:
My opinion is, the country is doctored
to death, and if President and Congress would go to sleep like Rip Van Winkle,
the country would go on under natural influences, and recover far faster than
under their joint and several treatment.
(William T. Sherman, letter to General
Ulysses S. Grant, February 14, 1868, in William Tecumseh Sherman, Memoirs of William T. Sherman, p.922)
If someone should ask you, “Who runs the country?”, the
correct answer is, “no one.” Plenty
pretend to, and many others wish to, but none do and none can, and we would all
be better off if they would stop trying.
Our nation’s founders would have recoiled in horror at the question,
because they intentionally created a nation that no one could run. Why else have three branches of a federal government,
one of which is divided into two separate houses, and state governments take
their share of governmental authority?
They had seen Europe and knew of Asia where people for thousands of
years had royally messed things up by trying to run their countries.
Instead, the American founders created a system where each
person would run his own life. The
leaders in government were to run the government, that for the most part was to
stay out of people’s lives and keep foreign governments at bay should they have
any thoughts of trying their hand at running the lives of Americans.
That vision of the founders has been fading. Today, make a list of the things that you can do that do
not involve some sort of authority or permission from government. It will not be a long list, and it has not
been getting any longer in recent years.
Then ask yourself if life has been getting any better. If it has, congratulate yourself on your
power to overcome.